The gear suggestion system is seemingly wrong and very annoying.

[xpstyle36]

So, I have used Zygor Guides for a good while now, and in the retail guide, the gear suggestion system is spot on.

Classic seems to be a different story though. It makes it very difficult to decide if I should replace gear or not... not to mention the stupid percentage improvements it suggests.

If it's just me, and I am misinterpreting it, let me know.

I have attached a screenshot of it doing this. Replacing my dungeon blue with a rubbish sword is apparently 17380.43% a good idea.

WoWScrnShot_012820_222048.jpg

Also. Where are the dungeon guides?

Regards,

Dane

[ZG Support 1]

When you have a gear suggestion you think is wrong hold Shift and click on Decline to generate a gear system bug report to post here. Without knowing your class/spec and only seeing one item's stats in that picture I would have to agree with the gear system suggestion based on the stats you gain and lose in that picture. DPS is not normally a stat that has any score so if your blue weapon has not stats and is just better in dps then most likely it is not the better weapon for you. Remember, just because it has a different color or dropped in a dungeon does not automatically make it better for you.

As for the dungeon guides, we have not created any dungeon guides for classic yet. I do not know if or when we might make dungeon guides for classic.

[ealtorfer]

I am noticing something similar to this person where Zygor does not seem to be considering stats on items with affixes.

For example, I currently have equipped:

[Sentinel Boots of the Monkey] 72 Armor +8 Agility +7 Stamina

However, Zygor keeps suggesting that a _huge_ upgrade is:

[Insignia Boots] 69 Armor +8 Agility +4 Stamina (1151.38%!!!)

It shows this item is +4 Stamina and +8 Agility better than my Sentinel Boots of the Monkey, which it is clearly not. Any thoughts on why this might occur?

[ZG Support 1]

We are checking into it to get it fixed.

[Zwox]

Item scoring seems broken atm.

https://imgur.com/ljTcyBt

[ironbum]

Agreed. Item scoring seems to be broken in a couple of areas:
The Good:
-the stats for classes/builds are pretty decent out of the box
-stats can be edited if you know what you really want.

The Bad:
-the algorithm when comparing item stats seems to not be consistent
-green/special abilities of an item are completely ignored.

For now I have turned it off.
Kiwi gives better info if you know your stats or Pawn if you are levelling a more unknown class to you and just want it to recommend something.

It would be awesome if this worked though and tbh would prefer this working properly than anything with the auction house..

[imasav]

I too can confirm that item scoring seems to be broken. For example, on my disc priest, it'll tell me a leggings with 4 agility and 4 stam is better than my 4 spirit 4 int. Like, what? Haha, makes no sense but I see you guys are made aware. Just here to confirm this is still a problem.

[jymz]

would also appreciate the system looking at enchants. kind of annoying to have the guide wanting to replace my skinning knife with +30 spellpower every time I pick up a white dagger.